We built a list of Google's best-rated roofing companies in 150 cities. Then we asked ChatGPT, logged out, who the best roofing company in each one is. In 148 of those cities it named a company. In 2 it gave advice on how to choose instead.
Of the 148 it named, 32 times the company was the same one Google rates number 1. That is 22%. Count its picks in Google's top three and the figure is 34%. Count anywhere in the top 20 and it is 81%. The other 19% of the time, the company it named was not on our list at all.
What ChatGPT named for roofers
Start with what that 81% means. ChatGPT is not sending buyers to bad roofers. Most of the time it names a company with a strong Google record. But the best record on the list is usually not the one it says first.
The more interesting number is reviews. The median company ChatGPT named had 421 Google reviews. The middle company on those same lists had 80. The company it chose tends to be well known, not just well rated.
How roofing compares with every trade
Across all 20 trades and 2,769 lists, ChatGPT named Google's number 1 in 22% of them. Roofing lands on the same 22%, so on that one measure roofers are typical.
Roofing is a little less tidy below the top. Across every trade, 40% of its picks were in Google's top three and 85% were somewhere in the top 20. For roofing those are 34% and 81%. The median pick across all trades had 260 reviews against 61 for the middle company. Roofing runs higher on both, 421 and 80. Roofers fight over review counts harder than most trades, and the data shows it. The full study has the rest of the trades.
Where ChatGPT and Google named the same roofer
When the two agree, it is usually a company that has both a perfect rating and a lot of reviews behind it. New York is a clean example. Google's number 1 on our New York roofing list is Paragon Chimney & Roofing of Downtown Brooklyn, rated 5.0 with 670 reviews. ChatGPT named Paragon Chimney and Roofing of NYC, the same business with a slightly different name, with the same 5.0 and 670.
Notice that this is not a small 5.0. Anyone can have a perfect rating after a handful of happy customers. A 5.0 held across 670 reviews is a different thing, and both Google's ranking and ChatGPT's answer pointed at it.
Where it went for the bigger review count
Houston is the opposite case. On our Houston roofing list, Google's number 1 is 314 Roofing Solutions, rated 5.0 with 1,193 reviews. ChatGPT did not name it. It named Amstill Roofing, which sits 10th of 20 on the list, rated 4.9, with 1,841 reviews.
Phoenix is starker. On the Phoenix roofing list, Google's number 1 is Arizona Roofing and Restoration, rated 5.0 with 137 reviews. ChatGPT named Arizona Roofers, also 10th of 20, rated 4.9, with 933 reviews.
In both cities the company ChatGPT chose was a tenth of a point lower in rating and well ahead in reviews. A buyer looking at the Phoenix numbers on paper might call 5.0 against 4.9 a win for the first. ChatGPT did not.
What this suggests for a roofer
This is a read, not a measurement. We cannot see inside ChatGPT, and it answers differently from one ask to the next. We asked once per list.
With that limit stated, here is what I think is going on. ChatGPT answers from what it has read. A roofer with hundreds or thousands of reviews has usually been written about in more places too: their own site, the directories, local news, and the pages that mention them. A 5.0 with 137 reviews and little else online gives it far less to work with than a 4.9 with 933.
That would explain why the pick sits 10th on a list ranked by rating and still gets named first. The ranking rewards a clean record. The answer seems to reward being easy to find and easy to vouch for.
It would also explain why some companies fall outside the list entirely. In the 19% of lists where the pick was not in the top 20, ChatGPT was still naming someone. In Los Angeles it named All In Roofing, in Philadelphia Liberty Roofing Inc, and in San Diego Build Brothers Inc. We did not rank those companies in our top 20, and I would not read more into it than that.
What to do if you own a roofing company
First, ask ChatGPT yourself. Log out, type the question a homeowner would type for your city, and write down the first name it gives. Do it a few times, since the answer moves. If it is not you, find out who it is and look up their review count next to yours.
Second, do not stop asking for reviews because your rating is already high. A 5.0 helps on Google. It does not seem to be the thing that gets you named. Keep the count growing, and keep the rating honest.
Third, give the AI more to read about you. That means a real website that says what you do and where, listings that match, and press or interviews when you earn them. This is the work we do in AI Search, for $2,000 a month. We do not promise a ranking, because nobody controls ChatGPT. We promise the work, and we check the answers and show you the score.
The button below opens a box where you can ask ChatGPT about your own company. It takes a minute, and it tells you where you stand.
How we built this: for each trade and city we pulled 30 Google Maps results and kept companies that were open, filed under the trade, in the area, with at least 5 reviews. We ranked them by rating weighted by number of reviews and showed the top 20. We asked ChatGPT once per list, logged out, and recorded the first company it named. Answers vary from one ask to the next, so treat each city as one sample.