We asked ChatGPT who is best 2,769 times. It agreed with Google 22% of the time.

One question per list, the one a buyer types: who is the best roofer, plumber or HVAC company in town? 20 trades, 150 cities. Here is how often ChatGPT's first pick was the company Google rates best, and what its picks had in common.

Jacob M. Ochs, founder of OwnersFirm November 16, 2026 6 min read

Every list on ownersfirm.com/top starts the same way. We pull the Google Maps results for one trade in one city. We keep the companies that are open, filed under that trade on Google, in the area, and rated by at least five reviews. Then we rank them by rating, weighted by how many reviews stand behind it. The top 20 make the page.

Then we ask ChatGPT, logged out, the question a buyer would type. Who is the best roofer in St. Louis? Who is the best HVAC company in Charlotte? We record the first company it names and put it on the page next to the list.

We did that for 20 home-service trades in 150 U.S. cities, which came to 2,769 lists. In 2,760 of them ChatGPT named a company first. In the other 9 it gave advice on how to choose instead. Here is how often its first pick was the company Google rates best.

2,769 squares, one per list. 610 bright gold: ChatGPT named Google's number 1. 489 dim gold: number 2 or 3. 1,239 pale: number 4 to 20. 422 outlined: not in the top 20. 9 dots: no company named.
One square for each of the 2,769 lists, in order from the best match to no match.

Where ChatGPT's first pick sat on the Google list

  • 22%Google's number 1. 610 lists.
  • 18%Number 2 or 3. 489 lists.
  • 45%Somewhere from 4 to 20. 1,239 lists.
  • 15%Not in the top 20 at all. 422 lists.
  • 9No company named. It gave advice instead.

Count its picks at number 2 and 3 as well, and 40% of the time it named one of Google's top three. 85% of the time its pick is somewhere in the top 20, so it is not recommending bad companies. But four times out of five, the company with the best Google record in town is not the one it names first.

A great Google rating gets you on the list. It does not get you named.

What ChatGPT's picks had in common

The pattern that jumps out is review count. Across the lists where ChatGPT's pick made the top 20, the median pick had 260 Google reviews. The middle company on those same lists had 61. More than a quarter of the time, its pick was the single most reviewed company on the list. Its picks were rarely weak on rating, either. About 1 in 9 was rated below its list's average.

The company ChatGPT named first260
The middle company on the same list61
Median Google reviews, across the 2,338 lists where ChatGPT's first pick made the top 20.

Three lists show the shape of it.

Every one of those picks is a well-rated company. None of them is the best-rated one. They are the ones with the most written about them, and I think that is the real point.

We cannot see inside ChatGPT, so take this as a read, not a measurement. It answers from what it has read. A company with thousands of reviews has usually been written about in a lot of other places too: its own website, the directories, the local news, the articles that mention it. A 5.0 with 100 reviews and a thin website gives it very little to read.

Where ChatGPT agreed with Google, and where it did not

The gap is not the same in every trade. Pest control is where the two agree the most. ChatGPT's first pick was the Google number 1 in 44% of cities and on the list 95% of the time. In Boston, Phoenix and Miami it named the same pest control company Google ranks first. Foundation repair, house cleaning, HVAC and gutters are where they agree the least, about 1 time in 7. Remodeling has the most picks from off the list: about a quarter of them were not in the top 20.

Lists counts the lists where ChatGPT named a company first. Trades with fewer lists had fewer cities with at least 10 companies that qualify.
TradeListsNamed Google's No. 1In the top 3In the top 20
Pest control15044%59%95%
House painting14941%58%89%
Tree service14831%47%87%
Concrete13726%47%80%
Electricians15023%49%87%
Roofing14822%34%81%
Garage doors14222%39%85%
Landscaping14821%36%83%
Fencing14620%38%90%
Water treatment8120%42%88%
Flooring14220%44%79%
Remodeling14820%38%74%
Siding11119%35%77%
Window replacement13418%35%86%
Plumbing15017%38%83%
Solar11916%35%88%
Gutters14315%32%87%
HVAC15015%29%85%
House cleaning15014%27%85%
Foundation repair11413%32%83%

What this means if you own the company

  1. Your rating is the price of entry. ChatGPT rarely names a company with a weak record. Keep asking every happy customer for a review. It is the one part of this every owner controls.
  2. Ask it yourself, logged out. Open a private window, go to ChatGPT without signing in, and ask who the best company in your trade is in your town. Ask a few times. The answer can change from one ask to the next, which is why our lists show one answer and call it one answer. The box on our homepage sets the question up for you.
  3. Give it something to read. If the company across town has thousands of reviews and years of pages about it, a better rating alone will not move you past it. What moves the answer is what has been written about your company, in your town, in the places AI reads. That is the work behind AI Search.

Nobody controls ChatGPT, and we do not promise anyone a ranking. We promise the work, and we check the answers and show you the score. For one client, Jones Air & Water, an automated check asked ChatGPT two buying questions 10 times each, logged out, and it named Jones first all 20 times. That is one client, not a promise.

How we did it, and what it cannot tell you. The Google Maps data is what each search returned when we pulled it, 30 results per trade and city, and ratings and review counts move every day. Listings named only for a search, like "near me", are left out. ChatGPT was asked once per list, logged out, and we kept the first company it named. Asked again, it can name someone else. Names are matched to the list automatically, and a pick only counts as on the list when the names match, so a few picks counted as off the list may be the same company under a slightly different name.

No business paid to be on any list, and a list that includes an OwnersFirm client says so on the page. Every list, with its own method note and ChatGPT's answer, is at ownersfirm.com/top.

Jacob M. Ochs
Founder, OwnersFirm · USMC veteran · Boeing alum

Jacob is a USMC veteran and Boeing engineering alum. He built and sold Marketing by Magnet, sold his half of Rocket Tint, and now runs OwnersFirm. Read the full bio

What does ChatGPT say about your company?

Ask it yourself in a minute on our homepage, or book a 15 minute Zoom with the OwnersFirm team and we will look at the answer with you.